Beyond the Economy: Capitalism as a Mode of Subject Formation

Capitalism is commonly analysed through markets, property, production, labour, inequality, and growth. These dimensions are indispensable, but they do not fully explain why people participate in arrangements that may exhaust, discipline, or disadvantage them. This lesson expands economic critique by examining how institutions organise desire, aspiration, identity, attention, and the experience of freedom.

1. From Economic Structure to Everyday Life

An economic system becomes durable when it is reproduced through everyday practices. Employment shapes time, language, mobility, and self-worth. Consumer credit transforms future income into present obligation. Education organises aspiration through credentials and competition. Digital platforms turn communication, visibility, and social recognition into measurable activity. Public policy participates in these processes whenever it defines deservingness, responsibility, productivity, risk, or normal behaviour.

This does not mean that people are passive products of systems. Individuals interpret rules, negotiate constraints, cooperate, resist, and create alternatives. The analytical task is to understand how the field of possible action is structured before a person makes an apparently private choice.

2. Desire Is Socially Produced

In this course, desire is not reduced to an inner wish or a psychological deficiency. Desire is productive: it connects people, objects, institutions, signs, habits, and material flows. Advertising is only one visible mechanism. Workplace metrics, family expectations, professional identities, urban design, interfaces, rankings, and policy incentives all help produce what appears attractive, necessary, shameful, or possible.

A critical policy analysis therefore asks not only whether an incentive changes behaviour. It asks what kind of subject the intervention assumes and encourages. Does a welfare programme treat a citizen as a rights-holder, a risk score, a client, or a suspected claimant? Does an education policy cultivate inquiry, compliance, competition, or measurable performance?

3. Psychopolitics and Self-Government

Contemporary power often operates by encouraging people to manage themselves. The entrepreneurial subject is invited to treat skills, health, reputation, networks, and even leisure as investments. Control can become internal: individuals monitor performance, optimise attention, and interpret structural insecurity as personal failure. This differs from direct coercion but can coexist with it.

The concept of psychopolitics helps examine governance that works through motivation, emotion, identity, and self-evaluation. It should be used carefully. Not every effort at self-improvement is domination, and public institutions sometimes need behavioural knowledge to deliver services effectively. The ethical question is whether people retain meaningful choice, dignity, transparency, and the ability to contest decisions.

4. Public Policy as Subject Formation

Policies classify populations, create incentives, distribute recognition, and communicate moral expectations. A tax credit may support families while privileging one household model. A digital identity system may increase access while making participation dependent on data infrastructures. Unemployment requirements may connect people with work while producing surveillance and stigma. Policy evaluation must therefore examine administrative outcomes and subjective consequences together.

5. Case Lens: Platform Labour

Platform labour illustrates how economic and subjective power combine. Workers may value flexibility, yet algorithms distribute visibility, tasks, ratings, and income. The platform presents the worker as independent while continuously modifying behaviour through prompts, incentives, and performance scores. A conventional analysis measures wages, hours, and legal status. A micropolitical analysis additionally studies anxiety, self-presentation, competition, dependency, and how the interface makes control appear as personal choice.

6. Analytical Precautions

• Do not assume that every preference is false consciousness.
• Do not replace empirical research with philosophical vocabulary.
• Distinguish persuasion, incentive, dependency, coercion, and legal obligation.
• Ask how effects differ across class, gender, disability, age, citizenship, and location.
• Identify possibilities for agency and collective organisation as well as constraint.

Prototype Exercise: Desire–Institution Map

Select one policy or public service. Create a map with five layers:

1. Material flows: money, labour, data, infrastructure, and resources.
2. Institutional actors: agencies, vendors, communities, professionals, and intermediaries.
3. Categories and signs: eligibility labels, scores, credentials, messages, and interfaces.
4. Desired conduct: behaviours, identities, aspirations, and forms of self-monitoring encouraged by the system.
5. Consequences and alternatives: benefits, burdens, resistance, and possible redesign.

Enrolled learners may use the linked AI Laboratory prototype to generate counterarguments or identify missing relationships. AI must not be used as evidence of what affected people feel. Validate interpretations through credible research and, where appropriate, participation with real stakeholders.

Reflection Questions

• What kind of person does the selected policy imagine?
• Which choices are technically available but practically difficult?
• How are structural problems translated into individual responsibility?
• What changes would increase capability and dignity without removing useful support?

Key Takeaway

To move beyond the economy is not to abandon economic analysis. It is to connect markets and institutions with the production of conduct, meaning, and desire. Public policy becomes more responsible when it evaluates not only what people receive or do, but also the social relations and forms of subjectivity that an intervention helps create.

---

Slide deck

A ten-slide HTML presentation summarising this lesson. It prints, translates and reads on any device.

A ten-slide presentation of this lesson. Every slide is plain HTML, so it prints, translates and reads on any device.

12345678910

Click a number to jump to a slide, or scroll the deck sideways.